Wheelgun Wednesday: Single-Action Revolvers For Any Budget Range

Zac K
by Zac K
The "Black Beauty" Colt Single Action Army revolver [Rock Island Auction Company]

For reasons that go far beyond the actual historical record, no firearm is as closely associated with America’s western frontier as the Colt Single Action Army revolver. Introduced in 1873, the original Colt SAA was in production until 1940, with 357,859 revolvers built during that run. Production rebooted in the 1970s and continues until today, but Colt’s modern Peacemaker is an expensive revolver, just as it always has been. Here’s a look at competing products, at price levels for anyone.


Wild West Six-Shooters @ TFB:

Heritage Rough Rider

Heritage Manufacturing makes these revolvers so affordable, they’re practically giving them away. The lowest MSRP I’ve found on their website is $168.99, but prices vary widely because they offer these revolvers in such a wide variety of configurations—different barrel lengths, different grips, different finishes, different sights and in most cases, your choice of .22LR or .22 Magnum—or both, if you buy an extra cylinder, which is easy to switch out.

The Heritage Rough Rider comes in a wide variety of finishes and barrel lengths. The frame is made of zinc alloy to keep costs down, like other low-priced revolvers, including the Wrangler below. These handguns are made in the USA. [Heritage Manufacturing]

Heritage also has a 9-shot revolver built on the same basic design for $228.99, which is a very low price for a high-capacity revolver (can we say that, without sounding ridiculous?). If you’re just looking to try out a single-action revolver without spending a lot of cash, the Heritage Rough Rider has you covered. See TFB’s previous review of the Rough Rider here.

Ruger Wrangler

Ruger’s take on the affordable single-action revolver took the world by storm at its 2019 debut. Like the Rough Rider, the Wrangler comes in a variety of barrel lengths, finishes and grips, although there isn’t as much choice as there is with Heritage’s revolver. But Ruger buyers like the fact that, for a $269 MSRP, they can buy a single-action from a company with decades of experience making quality Peacemaker-style revolvers.

The Wrangler’s Cerakote finish is extremely corrosion-resistant. Currently, these are built at Ruger’s factory in Prescott, Arizona. [Ruger]

Starting with 1953’s Single Six rimfire, Ruger has been making great affordable, reliable single-action revolvers for more than seven decades. The .22LR Wrangler continues that tradition, along with the Super Wrangler, which comes with a cylinder in .22 Magnum. While it’s more expensive than the Heritage revolver, Ruger’s budget SAA clone is so well-regarded for reliability that it might be one of the best bang-for-your-buck revolvers of all time. The only major downside is Ruger’s insistence on six-shot capacity; the cylinder is beefy enough that it could easily handle more rounds. See our review of the Wrangler here, and the Super Wrangler here.

EAA Bounty Hunter

If you’re tired of shooting rimfires and want to move up to the big leagues, the EAA Bounty Hunter (actually made by Weihrauch in Germany) offers you the choice of .45 Long Colt, .44 Magnum or .357 Magnum. With an MSRP starting at $649, the Bounty Hunter has a classic look, with walnut grips and no safety beside the hammer’s transfer bar system. While there are rimfire versions of this revolver with a zinc alloy frame, the centerfire version has a steel frame and is a very beefy hand cannon for the price.

Previously, this design was built by JP Sauer, where Weihrauch bought the machinery when they started production—see a review by Sam S. on the German-built Hawes rimfire revolver here, which uses the same mechanism design. TFB hasn’t tested the centerfire Bounty Hunter, but they seem to be generally considered as high-quality revolvers, although the high-volume shooters of the cowboy action shooting community dislike the transfer bar safety, which was licensed from Ruger. Some shooters remove it.

Traditions 1873 Frontier Single Action

Coming in around a $654.95 MSRP, just slightly more than the Bounty Hunter, these made-by-Pietta revolvers offer the chance to pick from a wider range of barrel lengths, grips and finishes.

Traditions has shorter-barreled SAA clones for sale; this .357 revolver comes with a 3.5-inch barrel. Probably not your best choice for CCW, but you do you! [Traditions]

These are well-regarded for quality internals, good accuracy and a finish that holds up over use. TFB reviewed these early on, when they first started importing them to the US.

Cimarron Pistolero Dual Cylinder 9mm/357

Another revolver sneaking in under the $700 mark, with a $695.83 MSRP. This revolver is set apart by its capability to chamber 9x19mm ammunition, if you swap out the included cylinder chambered in this round. Nine-mil ammo is cheap, since it’s made in bulk for auto pistols, and if you’ve got a lot of it around or you just want to buy affordable centerfire ammunition, this revolver can be very appealing.

It’s a revolver that can shoot off the 9x19mm loads that are taking up space in your cabinet. [Cimarron]

And if you want some plain old-fashioned magnum hitting power, the ability to convert to .357 makes it all the more interesting. This revolver is made in Italy by Uberti, who’s been making repros forever.

Uberti El Patron Competition

Uberti also sells their single-action clones under their own name in the U.S.; this particular model is factory-tuned for competitive shooting.

With a trimmed-down hammer, 1860-pattern grips for larger hands and classic case coloring on the frame, this is a vintage-looking revolver that’s built to perform in cowboy action competition. The sights are fixed, but in CAS, you’re not generally allowed adjustable target-style sights on revolvers anyway. MSRP for these hand-tuned revolvers starts at $809.

Ruger New Model Single Six Convertible

Maybe you want a rimfire single-action, but you want a higher-quality product. Ruger’s got you covered with the Single Six Convertible, which ships with six-round cylinders for either .22 LR or .22 Magnum. MSRP is $829, but you’re getting a lot of revolver for your money.

The Single Six can handle hunting or target practice with adjustable sights. [Ruger]

With a steel frame, this gun is made to last a lifetime. There’s even a .17 HMR variant, along with versions shipped with 7, 9 or 10-round cylinders. Adjustable sights improve accuracy for target shooting or range time. This has been a cornerstone of Ruger’s revolver lineup for a very long time, and it is still the standard by which all rimfire revolvers are judged, even Ruger’s own models.

Cimarron Bad Boy Dual Cylinder 10mm/.38-40

Want a revolver chambered in a classic cowboy cartridge, but you also want enough hitting power to take down a grizzly if needed? Cimarron’s Bad Boy comes with two cylinders, chambered in either the modern 10mm Auto or the classic .38-40. MSRP is $985.99.

Old-school aesthetics meet proper, modern adjustable sights. [Cimarron]

Like the rest of their revolvers, this wheelgun is made out-of-house, actually manufactured by Uberti. An octagon barrel and classic army-style grip give it an old-school look, but the adjustable sights will make sure you’re shooting straight. It might look like an old cavalry pistol, but it’s built for the modern shooter.

Ruger Super Blackhawk Hunter

If you want a powerful hand cannon for hunting or self-protection from the largest bears, not the fun-and-games of cowboy action shooting, then Ruger is where most people’s search begins and ends, especially with the Super Blackhawk line.

A revolver to help you survive and thrive in the wilderness. [Ruger]

These beefy stainless steel revolvers will shrug off the elements on the Alaska coastline or in the mountains of Montana. Adjustable hunting-style sights, with fiber-optic insert in front, will do for self-defense or close-range hunting. Clamp a long eye relief scope onto the mounting slots machined into the barrel, and you can blast away at far longer range. A handgun that is built to save the lives of its users, and to enable hunting success after they’ve done the rest of the work of getting into range. MSRP is $1,249.

Magnum Research BFR

If you want to step up from the most powerful pistol cartridges, the Magnum Research BFR allows you to chamber heavy-hitting rifle cartridges in a handgun, including 350 Legend, .45-70 and .30-30. Obviously, it looks a lot different from your classic 1873-pattern revolver, with a stretched-out cylinder to handle these rifle rounds, but the idea is basically the same, just scaled up.

A handgun with this level of construction is not going to be cheap—MSRP for the rifle-caliber options starts at $1,574. But this revolver offers hitting power that used to be restricted to single-shot pistols.

Colt Single Action Army

The classic. The original. The Peacemaker. Still in production, and while it is updated from the original model made more than 150 years ago, it is still basically the same revolver, available in 4.75-, 5.5- and 7-inch barrels.

The modern Colt SAA looks very close to the original. [Colt]

Colt doesn’t make a lot of these, but there’s still demand, and at an MSRP starting at $2,299, they can certainly afford to keep producing them. No, it doesn’t have the trick sites or fancy-pants stainless finish or nice wood grips that competitors offer for less money, but this is the original. If you want the accept-no-substitutes real-deal Peacemaker, this is it; better start saving!

Zac K
Zac K

Professional hoser with fudd-ish leanings.

More by Zac K

Comments
Join the conversation
 1 comment
Next